San Diego has become part of a new national experiment with guaranteed income, where governments and nonprofits give targeted families wireless cash payments to help them make ends meet.
Find our essential investigative journalism
Sign up for the weekly Watchdog newsletter for investigations, data journalism and more.
You may receive promotional material from time to time from the San Diego Union-Tribune.
The first guaranteed income program in the San Diego region began giving $500 a month to 150 low-income families in the South Bay in March, and two more local programs are launching this fall.
The county government will soon provide about $500 a month to hundreds of low-income families deemed at risk of neglect or abuse who would need intervention from the county’s child welfare system.
And two non-profits – Café X and Jewish Family Service – will provide $1,000 per month to 25 low-income Black women, with the hope of expanding that to 50 in the program’s second year.
Cities across the region could be next, as the state will soon award $35 million in competitive grants to cities looking to launch guaranteed income programs.
“There’s a lot happening, and it looks like there’s more to come,” said Chris Olsen, chief of staff at Jewish Family Services, which has a hand in all three local programs.
The goal of guaranteed income programs is to strengthen poor families by giving them money to use as they choose, whether for food, rent or medical expenses — or perhaps childcare that will allow a parent to start working. full time or take a higher position. paying job.
The money can also help cover living expenses while a person completes higher education or professional training, such as a two-year nursing degree or a real estate license.
Critics say guaranteed income goes against the American ideal that prosperity should require earning every dollar, and that handouts make people lazy. Some also express concern that it could fuel inflation, or allow employers to not pay a living wage.
But data from fast-growing guaranteed income programs across the nation so far tell a different story. For example, a study of a guaranteed income program launched in Stockton in 2019 showed that 28 percent of participants had a full-time job at the beginning of the programs, and 40 percent did after one year.
The data from such programs also show that participants are more likely to use the money to overcome obstacles to finding a full-time job, such as the need for childcare, than to use the money for used to cover expenses so they can do less work. .
During the first three months of the $2.9 million San Diego pilot program already underway, called San Diego For Every Child, participants spent 41 percent of their stipends on food, 23 percent on retail items, 20 percent on transportation and 9 percent on utilities and other households. expenses.
Guaranteed income is an offshoot of universal basic income, an idea that gained popularity during the pandemic that governments should give everyone a monthly cash payment so they can afford the basics of life.
Critics of universal basic income say it fails to target those who need handouts the most, but guaranteed income programs, which they prefer, put money in the right places.
Another difference is that universal basic income is often described by supporters as a substitute for other programs that make up the social safety net, while guaranteed income is usually intended as a supplement rather than a substitute.
Guaranteed income programs also allow governments and non-profits to try to solve societal problems, such as child hunger or low levels of Black home ownership, by giving people cash and seeing how it changes things.
“Most guaranteed income programs are tasked with finding solutions to some societal issue or finding ways to fix an existing public system that may be broken,” Olsen said.
Supporters hope the results of guaranteed income programs could help governments or non-profits handle social problems in more efficient and compassionate ways.
The programs can target a geographic area, people of a certain income, people from certain races or ethnicities or people at risk of certain social problems.
San Diego For Every Child limited participation to four at-risk neighborhoods in the South Bay: National City and San Diego Encanto, San Ysidro and Paradise Hills neighborhoods.
Organizers chose those neighborhoods because county officials said they were the parts of the region most hurt by the pandemic. The 150 families selected from 1,533 who applied have an average household income of $30,405.
In contrast, the county register will not have a geographic component. Instead it will target low-income families across the county who have been deemed at risk of intervention from child welfare services.
“They have loving parents who are constrained by a lack of resources,” said County Supervisor Terra Lawson-Remer, who is leading the county’s pilot program.
County officials say about 60 percent of children who enter the foster care system do so because of so-called parental neglect, but many are often just symptoms of poverty. Parents can’t afford enough food, or they leave their children at home alone while they work because they can’t afford childcare.
Lawson-Remer said the $7.5 million in federal pandemic stimulus the county will spend on the program should be viewed as an investment that could reduce costs for foster parents in the future.
“We have to be willing to spend the resources upfront,” she said. “We can spend less on foster parents, and we can keep more families together. It’s exciting.”
But Lawson-Remer emphasized that a component of the program will be a thorough analysis to see if it is effective. While it could be a national model, it could also be a total failure.
“We’re not going to stick with programs that don’t work, so the numbers are going to be important,” she said.
A third local program, called the Black Women’s Resilience Project, aims to improve the lives of low-income Black women with cash and coaching focused on Black culture and self-actualization, economic mobility, mental health and participation civil.
Khea Pollard, who also leads the San Diego For Every Child project for Jewish Family Service, said one goal of the $2.8 million Black Women’s Resilience Project is fighting the widening of the racial wealth gap during the pandemic.
Pollard said the San Diego For Every Child project is going smoothly as it enters its eighth month of cash payments.
“Local people are taking advantage of the funding to fill gaps,” she said
To help outsiders understand the impact of the project, 13 families are taking part in a storytelling experiment in which they will describe the challenges they face and how the cash payments have helped them.
“The goal is to change some of the main narratives about working class people,” Pollard said. Meanwhile, Jewish Family Service is preparing for the second group of families in the San Diego For Every Child project. That group, which is expected to start next summer, will include 1,000 families – more than six times the original group of 150 families.
Since 2020, around 50 guaranteed income programs have been launched across the country, and many more are being planned.
The city of Los Angeles launched its own guaranteed income program last year with $38 million in city money. Stockton made national headlines when it launched one of the nation’s first guaranteed income programs in 2019.
It is unclear whether future guaranteed income programs will be run primarily by governments, nonprofits, or some combination of the two.
Olsen said the hybrid approach could make sense in the long term because the programs aim to solve societal problems, a common goal of both nonprofits and governments.
Canada does not have a universal basic income (UBI), but the financial impacts of COVID-19 have led to renewed interest in the potential benefits of a UBI program.
What is guaranteed minimum income?
Guaranteed minimum income (GMI), also known as minimum income (or mini-income for short), is a social welfare system that guarantees an income sufficient to live on for every citizen or family, provided that certain eligibility conditions are met, usually: citizenship; means test; and either availability to participate in …
What is guaranteed minimum income benefit? A guaranteed minimum income benefit (GMIB) ensures that an annuitant receives payments regardless of market conditions. This minimum payout is determined in advance by assessing the future value of the initial investment. This option only applies to annuities that plan to annuitize their annuity.
What is meant by guaranteed income?
A guaranteed minimum income, known as a minimum income or basic income guarantee (BIG), is a supplementary model that provides varying amounts of additional funding to any earnings of a low-income citizen, based on demonstrated need.
What are the benefits of guaranteed income?
Guaranteed Basic Income provides cash payments to specific targeted communities of people. This system specifically targets inequality by giving the money to those who need it: people living below the poverty line, those with inconsistent or no income, and marginalized communities , especially communities of color.
Is guaranteed income taxable?
Like ordinary income, the guaranteed payments do not require income tax and FICA tax would be paid on salary. However, the guaranteed payments are subject to self-employment taxes and estimated income taxes.
Does the US have a guaranteed minimum income?
Although, at the federal level, policy makers have never implemented UBI, recent policies have come to fruition. “The most similar thing we have is things like the Child Tax Credit,” Marinescu says, adding, “that’s not universal, but for anyone who has kids, it gives them money without any other conditions. â
What is the basic income grant?
A basic income guarantee is a government commitment to ensure that everyone has a minimum level of income to meet their basic needs. This is done through a regular cash transfer or grant. Not all basic income guarantees are the same. A key point of difference is whether the guarantee is universal or targeted.
What is American guaranteed income?
Guaranteed income pilot programs traditionally provide unconditional, individual, regular cash payments designed to support the basic needs of recipients. The budget for the pilot program is $35 million (General Fund) over five years.
How does guaranteed basic income work in Canada?
This program would guarantee all Canadians between the ages of 18 and 64 an income of at least 75% of the Low Income Measure (LIM, a collective measure of the Canadian poverty line), or a basic income of approximately $18,300 for individuals and $25,900 for a couple.
How does a guaranteed income program work? A guaranteed income is a monthly cash payment given directly to individuals. It is unconditional, with no strings attached on how to wear it and no work requirements. It is intended to supplement, rather than replace, the existing social safety net.
Does everyone get Universal Basic Income Canada?
Guaranteed basic income (GBI) is the system most people are referring to when talking about basic income in Canada. It is a contingent income system, meaning that monthly payments only go to families and individuals on lower incomes.
What is the basic income amount in Canada?
$13,808 for tax year 2021, $14,398 for tax year 2022, and. $15,000 for the 2023 tax year, and indexed for inflation for subsequent years.
Does Canada have a guaranteed income?
The Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS) is a monthly payment you can get: if you’re 65 or over. you live in Canada. you receive the Old Age Security (OAS) pension.
How much would guaranteed basic income be in Canada?
Universal basic income experiments in Canada The program targeted low-income individuals and families, guaranteeing a minimum income (for example, a family of four will receive at least $16,000 a year).
How much will universal basic income be?
Democratic presidential candidate Andrew Yang made universal basic income a key pillar of his 2020 campaign, which helped bring national attention to the issue. UBI proposals vary in amount, though Yang’s plan would give every American adult $1,000 a month from the federal government.
How much would a guaranteed income cost?
A UBI that would provide every American adult with $12,000 a year would cost the US government more than $3.1 trillion a year – a sum equal to about 90% of all the money the federal government collected in revenue last year. Advocates of guaranteed incomes say wealth taxes, such as those proposed by Democratic Sens.
When was universal basic income introduced?
But it was in 1848 that Unconditional Basic Income was first proposed without ambiguity at the level of the whole country.
When did the idea of universal basic income start? The beginning of the 20th century. Around 1920, support for basic income began to grow, mainly in England. Bertrand Russell (1872-1970) argued for a new social model that combined the advantages of socialism and anarchism, and that a basic income should be a vital part of that new society.
Who first proposed universal basic income?
It could be argued that Thomas Paine, in Agrarian Justice, 1796/1797 was the first person to propose a system that closely resembles a basic national income in the United States. His idea was that a couple of “basic incomes” for young people, in their 20s, financed by inheritance tax, were urgently needed, and also a question of justice.
Who introduced universal basic income?
The initiative was started by Peter Hofer. His proposal proposed a basic income of €1,200 for every Austrian citizen. 2020: A study by the University of Oxford found that 71% of Europeans are now in favor of a basic income.
Was Milton Friedman universal basic income?
The American economist Milton Friedman proposed a basic income in the form of a negative income tax in his 1962 book Capitalism and Freedom, and again in his 1980 book Free to Choose.
What countries have implemented a universal basic income?
Countries That Tried Universal Basic Income
- United States. The United States has tried several programs in the spirit of Basic Income. …
- Canada. Canada has experimented with several Basic Income programs. …
- Brazil. …
- Finland. …
- Namibia. …
- India. …
- A Summary of Countries That Have Tried Universal Basic Income.
Where has universal basic income worked?
Stockton’s Universal Basic Income Experiment Boosts Employment and Well-Being Independent researchers found that the first year of a universal basic income experiment in Stockton, Calif., improved recipients’ job prospects, financial stability and overall well-being.
Which countries have basic universal income?
Only two countries had basic national income programs: Mongolia and Iran. These programs only lasted a short time before they were discontinued, and there is little certainty as to whether they were successful or not.