San Diego began a long-awaited strike on street vendors last week after operators opened stores in Gaslamp, Mission Beach and other places without a little surveillance for years.
The law was a response to an increase in the number of street vendors, who may have shown an entrepreneurial spirit, but neighborhood groups say they are undermining the character of parks, beaches and business districts.
Critics say the city’s new law on suppliers is too punishable and aggressive, noting that it bans sellers from most busy and profitable areas. They also say it has a racist overtone because most suppliers are colored immigrants.
The city will enforce licensing requirements and other elements of the new law, such as where sales are allowed, with a team of law enforcement officers (not police). The new law includes fines and the possible seizure of shopping carts for violating the rules.
Q: Did San Diego make the right call to deal with street vendors?
DA: It would be chaotic if we allowed anyone who wanted to open a table shop wherever they wanted at any time. Our parks and tourist attractions are places where San Diegans and visitors go to enjoy the beauty and tranquility of staying outdoors. It is unfair to renters to be in the shadow of street vendors. Our parks and sidewalks should never have been flooded with retail squatters.
Gary London, London Moeder Advisors
DA: But this is a slight “yes” because I believe that street selling brings life and spice to our city. Maybe just not en masse in central Balboa Park, or on the waterfront and sidewalks on the beaches. Separate certain areas, charge some fees, make sure the food is safe, create some sort of rotating system for sellers to compete in a limited space (giving preference to mom and dad owners) and you’re done.
Alan Gin, University of San Diego
YES: Of particular concern are food vendors operating without health permits and food handlers ’booklets due to health and safety issues. Another problem is the chaotic nature of these companies, which operate without complying with zoning or planning regulations. This leads to them appearing in high-traffic areas and dominant areas intended for public use. Creating “entrepreneurial zones” as permitted by law would help direct sellers to more suitable locations.
Bob Rauch, R.A. Rauch & amp; Associates
YES: It is difficult to strike a balance between encouraging entrepreneurship on the one hand and negatively affecting the character of parks, beaches and public spaces on the other. We pay taxes for quietly enjoying these spaces and don’t expect to see what looks like a huge sale on the beach or in our parks to give examples. The city had to take steps to clarify the rules of street vendors.
DA: I like the idea of giving people with limited resources the opportunity to progress on their own in economic terms. But when it starts to interfere with everyone else’s ability to use the sidewalk or the beach, then we have to draw the line. Street vendors are not a nuisance in many environments and should be encouraged. And of course, we need to make it easier to start and manage small businesses in more traditional places.
YES: Street vendors should be subject to some degree of permission to ensure food safety standards and overcrowding. The current measures to my taste seem to have been wrong on the restrictive side. Selected application to coastal areas, and uneven application makes swallowing difficult. Maybe a regulatory diet should be on the menu as well?
Chris Van Gorder, Scripps Health
YES: There are a lot of fixed companies that have to compete with sidewalk vendors. Sidewalk sellers must adhere to the same standards as fixed companies for safety reasons, if nothing else. Moreover, established businesses have struggled to survive the pandemic and now face new challenges of escalating labor and supply costs. If we do not equalize the conditions, these fixed companies will not be able to compete with the companies that are here today and disappeared tomorrow.
Norm Miller, University of San Diego
YES: Public space is valuable even without rent, except for license fees, which provides a competitive advantage over nearby retailers who pay rent and often sell the same goods. Requiring permits and charging fees level the playing field and better control the density of retail chaos in highly sought-after locations. It makes sense to assign the best locations and even vary fees per location if the city wants to further mitigate aggressive site holding strategies.
DA: But more will have to be done. All street vendors should be regulated and allowed similarly to their usual public safety and security counterparts. This should be carried out throughout the year, not just during the summer months to preserve local access and enjoy our sights, parks and beaches for all of San Diego, not just tourists. San Diego should look at cities like Carlsbad, Oceanside and Coronado as examples of stricter regulations and regulations on street sales.
David Ely, San Diego State University
YES: The council was supposed to establish regulations and restrictions for sellers after passing the Safe Sale on Sidewalks Act which decriminalized sidewalk sales in the state. Approved rules and regulations cover vendor permits, special permits for the sale of food products, the location of supplier equipment, and the location of vendor activities, all related to health and safety. The regulations represent a reasonable effort to balance the interests of businesses, residents, tourists and sellers.
YES: Public spaces maintained by the government for the enjoyment of all should not become commercial spaces for private enterprises. Moreover, street vendors compete directly with physical businesses that have to pay taxes, rents and employee benefits, thus creating an unfair competitive situation. The city should develop and enforce regulations to determine where and how street vendors may be allowed in certain areas.
Caroline Freund, School of Global Politics and Strategy UC San Diego
YES: Regulation of street vendors makes sense to keep open spaces for recreation and prevent crowds. In the future, it will be important to balance the environment for residents with the livelihoods of street vendors. A nominal license fee ($ 38), with designated sales space and an annual program evaluation is a good start. An escalation of fines makes sense, although it could be lower – research shows that high fines are much less likely to be paid and can lead to exclusion.
Haney Hong, San Diego County Taxpayers Assoc.
NO: The city should create barriers to entry for vendors on the sidewalks – by the way, people who want to work – when our cost of living doesn’t drive people to the streets. Homelessness really harms the “neighborhood character” or makes it difficult for the public to access, so these rules are just a distraction from the necessary hard work on housing. We’re keeping an eye on the ball, people. To the sellers, I am sorry that others are distancing your American dream.
Kelly Cunningham, San Diego Institute for Economic Research
Do you have an idea for the EconoMeter question? Email me at [email protected] Follow me on Twitter: @PhillipMolnar
* SAN DIEGO Named after the Gulf of San Diego, which Vizcaino renamed in 1602, in honor of the Franciscan, San Diego de Alcala de Henares, after whom his flagship was named.
Do more people live in San Diego or San Francisco?
San Diego vs San Francisco Population The population of San Diego is 1.43 million with a metro of 3.38 million. However, the population density is only 4,369 per square mile. By comparison, San Francisco is home to 881,000 people with a subway population of 4.72 million.
Is it cheaper to live in San Diego or San Francisco? Think carefully … The cost of living in San Francisco, California is 37.9% higher than in San Diego, California. You would have to earn a salary of $ 82,720 to maintain your current standard of living. Employers in San Francisco, California, typically pay 15.8% more than employers in San Diego, California.
Is San Fran or San Diego bigger?
The population of San Diego is 1.43 million, and the metro population is 3.38 million. However, the population density is only 4,369 per square mile. By comparison, San Francisco is home to 881,000 people with a subway population of 4.72 million.
Is San Francisco considered a large city?
It covers an area of 46.9 square miles (121 square miles) at the end of the San Francisco Peninsula, making it the second most densely populated major city in the U.S. after New York and the fifth most densely populated U.S. district, behind just four of New York City’s five municipalities.
How big is San Francisco vs San Diego?
San Francisco has just over half the population of San Diego, with about 860,000 residents compared to San Diego, with over 1,400,000 people.
Is it better to live in San Diego or San Francisco?
There is less crime and the weather is ideal with increased staff and lower cost of living, San Diego seems like the ideal place to live. However, if you love nice weather and want to be where a lot is going on in terms of entertainment, San Francisco might be the ideal location for you.
Où vivent les Français à Los Angeles ?
Culver City – Century City Culver City is a small municipality in Los Angeles, et Century City in the LA neighborhood, which is seduisent tous deux les young professions voire les étudiants, en raison de la proximité du campus de UCLA.
Pourquoi choisir la Californie ?
The natural parcels of the Pacific Ocean, in the vicinity of the vignobles, but also the high mountain and the dessert: you can travel all the way to California. It is possible to take the dessert to the sea or encore the plains of three bases altitude to the montagnes aux sommets enneigés en moins de deux heures.
Is San Diego a part of California?
San Diego, port and city, headquarters (1850) of San Diego County, Southern California, USA. It lies along the Pacific Ocean in San Diego Bay, north of the international border with Mexico and some 120 miles (195 km) southeast of Los Angeles.
Is San Diego part of Cali? The second largest city in California, San Diego County includes 18 incorporated cities and numerous other charming neighborhoods. The second largest city in California and the eighth largest in the United States, San Diego has a city population of nearly 1.3 million and more than 3 million residents across the county.
Is San Diego under California?
San Diego (/ ËŒsæn diËˆeÉªÉ¡oÊŠ / SAN dee-AY-goh, Spanish: [san ËˆdjeÉ £ o]; Spanish for ‘Saint Didacus’) is a city in the US state of California on the Pacific coast and just off the Mexican border.
Où se situ San Diego ?
The city is located in the extreme south of the United States, the two hours and the demise of the Los Angeles route, the main agglomeration of the State of California. It is located on the edge of the Bay of San Diego baths near the points of Point Loma and Coronado.
Pourquoi San Diego est connu ?
Visit San Diego, it is also profiteer than the climate of California to buller on the beach, or to immerse yourself in the culture and to surf! Mission Beach and Pacific Beach are the beaches of the city. The long promenade of Mission beach is warm and relaxing, with a surf shop.
Is San Diego California a state?
San Diego is a city in the US state of California on the Pacific coast.
Is San Diego State or city?
San Diego (/ ËŒsæn diËˆeÉªÉ¡oÊŠ / SAN dee-AY-goh, Spanish: [san ËˆdjeÉ £ o]; Spanish for ‘Saint Didacus’) is the capital of the US state of California on the Pacific coast and just off the Mexican border.
When did San Diego become a state?
The fort and mission were founded in 1769, which gradually expanded into a settlement under first Spanish and then Mexican rule. San Diego officially became part of the United States in 1848, and the city was named the seat of San Diego County when California gained statehood in 1850.
Is San Diego nicer than Los Angeles?
While many may be exhausted by the madness of life in LA, San Diego is a modest alternative that seems much more suburban. People are generally considered much kinder, and some polls rank San Diego as the friendliest city in America.
Is San Diego more expensive than Los Angeles? Los Angeles is 8.2% more expensive than San Diego. The cost of housing in Los Angeles is 6.8% more expensive than the cost of housing in San Diego.
Is San Diego or LA cheaper?
The answer is San Diego. San Diego wins by the nose because it is on average 13% more affordable than LA. With a score of 160/100 for San Diego versus 173/100 for Los Angeles, one thing is for sure; both cities are expensive. (For your information only, 100 is the national average.
What salary do you need to live in San Diego?
As you can see from our review of the cost of living in San Diego, a $ 100,000 salary should be enough to live comfortably in San Diego, provided you don’t spend too much money on travel, gambling, or luxury goods.
Is San Diego expensive to live in?
SAN DIEGO – Rental prices in the San Diego area are among the most expensive in the U.S., and rising costs far outpace prices in the West Coast since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, a Zumper report released Tuesday shows.
What is better Los Angeles or San Diego?
San Diego is safer The crime rate in San Diego is much lower (38.41) than in Los Angeles (55.6). Various crime indices support the argument that San Diego is a safer city. The possibility of safe walking alone during the day shows that Los Angeles (70.74) is less safe than San Diego (82.39).
Is San Diego the same as Los Angeles?
Both are big cities, but Los Angeles is definitely smaller than SD. Los Angeles is home to an incredible 4 million people, the second largest city in the United States, with a huge metropolitan population of 18.7 million. By comparison, San Diego is home to 1.4 million people with a subway population of 4.9 million.
How far is LA and San Diego?
Using downtown Los Angeles as a starting point, the distance between Los Angeles and San Diego is 118 miles, which takes at least 1 hour and 50 minutes without stopping and without traffic.